I really dislike words that have no definition other than a different form of themselves.
Leader – a person or thing that leads.
Leadership – the position or function of a leader
Talk about something with no real meaning—except when looking at the man-hours spent teaching and writing about it or the hundreds of millions of dollars spent on acquiring it.
And I find the practice of identifying ‘leaders’ early in their careers particularly repugnant for two reasons.
1. The idea that you can identify future ‘leaders’ from their actions on the playground or in high school or during their initial working years is inaccurate at best and stupid at worst.
Those identified as kids are the ones who excel at getting noticed, love the spotlight, have a good story to tell and are typically attractive and mainstream. The nerds and misfits are rarely noticed as future ‘leaders’—think Steve Jobs.
Picking them out for special training during their first five years of work eliminates all those who work for bad bosses or for companies where entry level hires are grunts with no real responsibility.
Choosing them because they have an MBA is really ridiculous—all the degree proves is that they could afford grad school (either had the money or went into debt) and that they made it through. That’s it.
Further, the ‘early leader’ approach eliminates all those late bloomers giving them far less opportunities to excel.
The second reason is much worse.
2.Those ‘chosen’ start getting extra attention and mentoring from day one of being identified, so the traits that got them noticed get stronger. Stronger isn’t always better.
They are anointed, singled out for greatness, they are special.
Being special sets you apart; suddenly you’re better than the others and that means that there must be different rules for you because you’re special, better—and entitled. An attitude best summed up by Richard Nixon when he said, “When the President does it, that means that it is not illegal.”
And that sense of being anointed a ‘leader’ is partly responsible for the current debacle.
Your comments—priceless
Don’t miss a post, subscribe via RSS or EMAIL